WASHINGTON — The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency opted not to finalize air emissions-estimating methodologies as part of the 20-plus-year-old Animal Feeding Operations Air Compliance Agreement.
“EPA’s enforcement office will work to end obligations under that agreement. Together, these actions bring closure to an agreement that has left thousands of American farmers without clear answers since 2005,” the agency said.
“These actions do not change EPA’s implementation of the Clean Air Act or its commitment to providing clean air for all Americans, including in rural communities around farms. However, it affirms that farmers will not need to worry about burdensome regulations being put in place.”
In 2005, following a National Academy of Sciences report which called for better ways to estimate air emissions from animal feedings operations, livestock and poultry farms that raise animals in confinement, EPA offered these farms the chance to sign a voluntary agreement and take part in the National Air Emissions Monitoring Study.
While the study’s goal was to develop methodologies farms could use to estimate their emissions, many stakeholders have raised concerns that the practicality of the study would have been more harmful than beneficial to America’s farmers by forcing burdensome regulatory requirements and that red tape would have hindered critical food production and impacted rural economies with overhead costs.
In the over two decades since, many participating farms have changed hands, closed, or modernized their barns and manure systems.
Farmers raising hogs, broiler chickens, egg-laying hens and dairy cows have waited that entire time without knowing what new permitting or reporting obligations might follow once the methods were finalized.
After evaluating the NAEMS data collected from 2005 to 2007, EPA concluded that the data are too old and too limited to support reliable methods.
The data reflect barn designs, herd sizes and manure practices that no longer represent how many farms operate today. As a result, EPA will not finalize the methodologies under the 2005 Air Compliance Agreement.
EPA will work to notify the approximately 2,600 AFOs subject to the 2005 Air Compliance Agreement of this action pursuant to the agreement, to the extent possible, and then terminate the agreement.
EPA will continue to work with the U.S. Department of Agriculture, land-grant universities and producers on practical, science-based ways to understand and reduce air emissions from farms and will continue to put farmers first in recognition of the vital role they play in feeding the nation.
“Farmers have been living for two decades with the threat that, at any moment, the EPA could come out with a new emissions framework that treats farms like major industrial facilities and requires farmers to scramble to seek onerous permits,” said Jeffrey Hall, EPA Office of Enforcement and Compliance Assurance assistant administrator.
Industry Support
National Pork Producers Council and National Milk Producers Federation representatives welcomed EPA’s decision that ends 20 years of uncertainty.
:quality(70)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/shawmedia/QNP3QGQE25D4FFCZCEOPBFVHEY.jpg)
“This move confirms what farmers have long known: Every farm is different, and there is no one-size-fits-all model to apply to them. Each farm should be judged on its own factors, including its location, its practices, its animals and its people. We’re grateful to EPA for listening to the farmers who feed this nation,” said NPPC President Rob Brenneman, an Iowa farmer.
:quality(70)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/shawmedia/V5BHCCSWLJFHXNGSQJNSEJHQ6M.jpg)
“Dairy farmers signed up for the NAEMS in good faith two decades ago, and they’ve been waiting ever since to find out what it would mean for their farms,” said Gregg Doud, NMPF president and CEO.
“You can’t measure a handful of farms years ago and use those numbers to set expectations for thousands of other farms. We appreciate EPA following the data and giving farmers a clear, final answer.”
:quality(70)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/shawmedia/UZFAFPN6M5DJDMTKH5XMZBUQIY.jpg)
“There’s a saying in our industry: when you’ve seen one dairy farm, you’ve seen one dairy farm,” said Clay Detlefsen, NMPF senior vice president and staff counsel.
“That’s why this approach was never going to work. Farms vary too much from one another and change too much over time. We’re grateful to EPA staff for their professionalism over the years, and we look forward to continued collaboration on practical, science-based approaches.”
:quality(70)/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/shawmedia/CVSQFIABCZFQVOJX2VRVTWTIIE.jpg)
:quality(70)/s3.amazonaws.com/arc-authors/shawmedia/ed197490-54d0-4d57-8027-b878c9f46789.jpg)